Sign in to follow this  
itsamoose

Nonviolent and Alternative mechanics

Recommended Posts

I've been interested recently in playing and really researching games that primarily don't involve violent mechanics, mechanics designed around a theme, or perhaps a unique take on traditional mechanics.  I've managed to find a few of these such as Cart Life and Papers, Please, but beyond a few of the more well known ones I really don't know where to look.  I was hoping that some of you know of some games/designers/companies that do this kind of thing, and perhaps could use this thread as a way to discuss the topic in general.

 

So far I've been compiling a list based on recommendations of friends:

 

Cart Life

Papers, Please

Crusader Kings 2

Maniac Mansion (I've heard a bit about this but can't seem to find a working version)

Beyond good and evil

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Racing-games, sports-games, simulation-games, dating-sims, match-three games, traversal-games, and exploration-games all focus on non-violent mechanics. I'm interested in helping you narrow down what you are looking for though. Are you looking for games that have explicit fail-states that are non-violent? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been interested recently in playing and really researching games that primarily don't involve violent mechanics, mechanics designed around a theme, or perhaps a unique take on traditional mechanics.

 

Maniac Mansion is all about microwaving hamsters!  Mechanically it's sentence construction, but then so is The Typing of the Dead.

 

And Crusader Kings is insanely violent, at least when played Nick Breckon-style.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

BG&E is definitely violent. 

 

Flower would be the most non-violent video gamey game I can think of.  Pixeljunk Eden is another one worth taking a look at (and another flower related one at that). 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Racing-games, sports-games, simulation-games, dating-sims, match-three games, traversal-games, and exploration-games all focus on non-violent mechanics. I'm interested in helping you narrow down what you are looking for though. Are you looking for games that have explicit fail-states that are non-violent? 

 

I was thinking more along the lines of something that can't necessarily be defined by a genre such as papers please, or is a unique twist on one such as Crusader Kings' idea where you can't conquer an area without a claim to it.  Beyond that, I'm interested in playing around with some games that add some unique rule or situation the player must interact with.  I'm not so much interested in the goal of the game, rather ones where the play deviates significantly from what you would expect.  At the shallow end I suppose something like Majora's mask would qualify, and on the deeper end something almost entirely abstract.  A lack of violence isn't necessarily required, just a starting point for something that is different.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would recommend Portal and PuzzleQuest or PuzzleQuest2 (I'm not sure which one would be a better introduction, but you probably won't want to play both of them). Portal turns a first-person shooter into one of the most engaging puzzle-games I've ever played. PuzzleQuest uses the match-three game mechanics in combination with RPG upgrades and abilities. So at first it is like any match-three, but as you choose which skills and equipment to upgrade, the player develops very specific strategies that completely change the way you will look at the board. PuzzleQuest 2 has a much more polished everything, but it felt too easy after obsessing over PuzzleQuest. I'm not sure if PuzzleQuest's story was better or if I was just feel nostalgia for the first game. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You might find some interesting examples if you look into serious/educational games. Often games intended to be educational will translate violent mechanics into non-violent ones, like how hunting in Oregon Trail became taking pictures of animals in Amazon Trail (though I have no idea if the violence was why it changed). Math teaching games also tend to have interesting mechanics that you wouldn't see in 'standard' games since people paying for games as entertainment most likely don't want to be using their brains too much.

(by a local developer here) has a unique addition based puzzle mechanic for defeating enemies, and if you looked at the multitude of small games in a Math Blaster or similar series' there would be probably dozens of neat little logic puzzles and math problems converted into mini games.

 

Some other interesting examples might be the work of another local indie studio, Subaltern Games, who made Neocolonialism (a game about amassing wealth to the detriment of everyone else "Many strategy games have featured traditional colonialism and warfare but few have explored the brutal reality of greed and indirect political control in the 21st century." quote from here) and is now developing No ********* Left Behind, which was described to me as "Prison Architect, but about schools"

 

edit: also Zoombinis

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are a seemingly infinite number of puzzle, adventure and exploration games that fit the bill, so I'll name a few from more unexpected genres.

 

Kerbal Space Program is a game about designing rockets and going into space (or frequently, having a bad problem and not going to space today).

 

Offworld Trading Company is a 4X game, only with no military component. You build a base, buy and sell resources on an open market, and eventually win by outmaneuvering your opponents economically and buying out their companies. You can pay to perform acts of industrial sabotage, but I wouldn't call it violent, and if it weren't for that mechanic, there wouldn't even be any conflict in the game besides the final buyout.

 

I'd also be inclined to count Minecraft as nonviolent. Sure you can hit a zombie with a sword, but it's very much not about that, and many players completely disregard those systems (either by playing on Peaceful, or just avoiding monsters by only going out in the daytime).

 

EDIT: There's also the "construction genre", whatever term you'd like to use that encompasses Sim City and Rollercoaster Tycoon, the games where you build stuff to make money roll in to build more stuff.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Impressions Games' city building games do have wars, but I believe many of the games have a choice whether you take over a peaceful city or a city with a military. In any case the vast majority of the mechanics are built around trade, happiness and access to resources.

 

Startopia is similar but there's more of a focus on bad actors in that game, so you do have some violence as criminals are subdued and jailed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the suggestions so far, they've been a big help.  Mainly the problem is that I'm sure games like this exist (as you have all pointed out) but I don't know where to find out about them since most websites are more geared to AAA game feature analysis (That's a nice way of saying 2 page stories about the newest gun in a shooter).

 

Something else I came across the other day is superhot, a first person shooter where time only moves when you do.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As Clyde said, Portal is a great non-violent game. There are a lot of other Portalesque non-violent shooters out there as well: Proteus, The Stanley Parable and Antichamber.

 

My suggestions would be Eufloria and Starseed Pilgrim

 

If you want to find out about them, why not watch Lets Plays and deconstruct them. Once you have done this a few times and developed a formula it is easy to see what they have in common. I do this with a lot of games as I just don't have enough time to play all the greats anymore. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dwarf Fortress doesn't have to be violent :P A less violent version of that is Banished.

 

Also for something completely abstract check out Antechamber.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It sounds like, if you haven't played Monkey Island, you need to play Monkey Island. It sounds like you'd really appreciate Insult Swordfighting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is something I think about a lot too, because it would be pretty cool if there were more games out there without violence. I believe it's a huge turn-off for a lot of people who otherwise might get into games.

 

Unfortunately, my design wheelhouse seems to be in action/arcade games which are maybe the most prone to combat/violence... And any abstraction of combat just seems to be just a bit silly.

 

Flower is a great example, maybe classic arcade stuff like Tapper too. Sorting and tidying up seem like good themes (Chibi Robo anyone?)

 

Anyone else have good examples of action/arcade stuff?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  1. Gone Home.
  2. Offworld Trading Company, still early access but it looks pretty sweet. I think there are a few violent mechanics, like sabotage, but it seems to be pretty light on that stuff.
  3. Shelter *Badger simulator

That's all I got. No two more different games have ever been on the same list.

 

Edit: *I had to add the prime badger simulator to this list of lists to cover every market.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would say that a great amount of interactive fiction is about solving problems through non-violent ways. Try checking out a game like Lost Pig that's good for IF beginners or the hundreds of games made using Twine.

 

There's also a lot of games that are primarily based around walking and experiencing the environment like Proteus and Dear Esther.

 

There's also the Myst series.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

PBS Game Show (aka Jamin from Kill Screen) weighed in on this recently

 

Some interesting thoughts. Pinball is violent!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the video link, didn't know they even had this show.    Crayon Physics, Quantum Conundrum, The Stanley Parable or the Vanishing of Ethan Carter are the 4 in my steam list that I've never had to do anything violent in, although I haven't made it all the way through the last one so who knows what's in store for me? :)

PBS Game Show (aka Jamin from Kill Screen) weighed in on this recently

 

 

Some interesting thoughts. Pinball is violent!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wii Sports

The Sims

Tony Hawks Pro Skater 2

Dance Dance Revolution

Jambo Safari

Rock Band

Viva Pinata

LittleBig Planet

Dustforce

Stuntman

Roller Coaster Tycoon

Theme Hospital

Where's My Water?

Zuma

Plenty of our favourite games! I could continue listing these for a long long time.

You could see how some games on this list might've deliberately come close to violence, and then denied it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wii Sports Resort is a good example of nonviolent action game in places. Parts of Saints Row 4 COULD be nonviolent. Someone should make a target-shooting 3d platformer or something

 

(someone may have started this project in UE4 and has failed to return to it)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this