Thanks for answering my question about not being able to get invested into a single game that much anymore.
When I think about the games I really couldn't put down over the recent years(Bioshock, Dead Space, Dark Souls) they are all games that get you in quick and they all have very sound, very clearly defined game mechanics that are actually fun to learn and work with.
Conversely, games that are just filled with nonstop, incoherent violence and nothing else like Max Payne 3 and basically all Call of Duty campaigns are just doing nothing for me now.
I've also lost all patience for cut scenes or standing in place and having dialog spoken to me so Bioware and to a slightly lesser extent Bethesda games aren't really doing it for me anymore. I just basically want my narrative to just be in audio logs or otherwise entirely implied through setting and tone.
Most recently, I was really impressed with FTL: Super short tutorial. Super easy to learn. And before the events start repeating over and over, the stories that come out of that game are actually pretty entertaining.
Also, I basically agreed with everything Jake said.