Jake

Twin Peaks Rewatch 52/53: The Return, Parts 17 and 18

Recommended Posts

Just now, UnpopularTrousers said:

Twin Peaks is just about the only way Lynch will get a big enough budget to make something, and I'm thus hoping for more things called Twin Peaks. But I'd prefer it if it made an even bigger break from what Twin Peaks has been up until this point.

 

 

This is what I want. Episode 8 was one of my favorite things ever and I would love to see Twin Peaks basically being used as an excuse to fund Lynch's art and trick people into watching something they normally wouldn't.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Episode 18 was quite draining. I felt really uneasy after it, and wanted to write a wall of text. I forced myself to read through the thread and calmer minds prevail, I think.

 

It's quite hard to know what to think. I'm left with the idea of GoodCoop initially setting out to do what he tried to do at the end of ep 17, and from that perspective the entire season was a diversion. I suppose stopping Laura from being killed undid all of Twin Peaks seasons 1-3. Quite The Return. Perhaps fitting in some ways.

 

I interpreted the scene at the motel as the Diane tulpa/Linda replacing the original Naido/Diane. If she was the original. Also, the motel RichCoop walks out of is different from the one Diane and Coop walk in. The sex scene was weird and uncomfortable, and I had no idea what to think of it, as I thought/kind of still do think that it wasn't Diane.

 

The ending was powerful, but also very much a declaration, a realization. A beginning of sorts. I never expected Laura to become an active character, and it was a lot of fun to see her, in this incarnation.

 

41 minutes ago, dartmonkey said:

 

I liked that Drunk peeled back his wound to reveal a band aid. Didn't see that coming.

 

I spent the entire time reading this thread hoping I'd get to do "Guys, it's a bandaid" joke :-)

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also, the Fireman/Giant seemed to capture Bad Coop, then intentionally release him into the Twin Peaks Sheriff Station to be defeated by Freddie. So, lore-wise, both of the coordinates Bad Coop got lead into a trap.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here are the things this season of Twin Peaks taught or reaffirmed for me:

 

Hell is other people.

So is Heaven.

There is precious little closure in this world.

Don't be a fucking tulpa.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Man this show wrecked me...so many questions! 

 

Edge of my seat during the station scene in episode 17.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Big Ed glimpsed a happy ending with Norma only to have the chain of events leading to it erased from existence.

 

if David Lynch wants to make more Twin Peaks, you'd be insane not to take it. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A season 4 would be awesome to see cooper and new Laura in a weird reflection version of twin peaks with a higher version of realism and where all the characters were dark versions of themselves. We could even see coop react to Trump as president.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Damn this show wrecked me... so many questions.. There has to be a fourth season surely??

I think this season had alot of ups and downs, one thing for sure though is my excitement of sitting down every Monday night to watch it knowing i had NO idea what I was about to see will be missed. Never experienced this with any show before.

I found Diane and Coop being together weird, and man Audrey? Hello? How's Annie?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Is everything we saw leading up to 17/18 now essentially wiped/meaningless? Of course those things had to happen to get Coop back in position to (attempt to) alter Laura's path. Or is the reality with Pete finding no body, and the existence of Carrie Page, an alternate reality? Or are those things completely independent of one another? And why was the girl at the Roadhouse scratching herself so much? This is my mind today.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
25 minutes ago, lethalenforcer said:

Is everything we saw leading up to 17/18 now essentially wiped/meaningless? Of course those things had to happen to get Coop back in position to (attempt to) alter Laura's path. Or is the reality with Pete finding no body, and the existence of Carrie Page, an alternate reality? Or are those things completely independent of one another? And why was the girl at the Roadhouse scratching herself so much? This is my mind today.

 

I don't know what happened but I don't think it's wiped out. Maybe Coop goes into an alternate universe though? The Secret History of Twin Peaks book has inaccuracies and apparently people questioned Mark Frost about it and he said it wasn't a goof. So maybe the history was slightly altered but not in a huge way?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, Don't Go There said:

I feel it is important to preface this with the statement that I really liked “The Return”, and I liked what we saw in Parts 17 and 18. It’s important, because I’m going to sound like I hated it. So, to be clear: I am an OG Peaks fan, I watched it when it first ran on ABC. I loved Fire Walk With Me from the very first time I saw it. And I have enjoyed The Return immensely.

 

That being said, nothing is perfect, and there are some problems I have with this series, and its conclusion. I’ve also been a Lynch fan from way back- I know that, in the battle between coherence of plot and surrealism, Lynch is going to pick surrealism every time. But there are some things that need to be addressed. Not “rules” really. But… well, here, let me just tell you:

 

1. Hawk was in the woods in episode 1. “Once again your log and I are on the same page.” Hawk gets to Glastonbury Grove, sees the red curtains… then nothing. We never find out where he got his information, we never find out what happened, or what was supposed to happen. It is never referred to again. Also, it seems to take place out of sequence, as the next scene with Hawk has him still mulling over the log’s initial message.

 

2. What happened to Becky? This we may already know, as Stephen is definitely hinting that he killed her. This would be a natural conclusion to where that story was headed. But we never see Bobby or Shelly react to this. Once Stephen pulls the trigger on himself-- and we see an ominous exterior shot of their trailer-- we never hear of it again.

 

3. Are we supposed to believe this “Jow-Day” entity is the Thing In the Glass Box? Because there is absolutely no reason to believe that. We are never told a thing about the thing in the box, about the thing in Part 8 that was spewing eggs, about the playing card with the silhouette, about the same design appearing on Hawk’s map. Are all these things even the same thing? Why is evil Coop seeking it out? What was his plan upon entering what I guess is the White Lodge?

 

4. “Jow-Day” is an ass-pull. I’m sorry, but it is. All “Judy” ever was, was a reference to a character in Fire Walk With Me that never ended up in the movie, but Lynch thought it sounded good enough to keep. The “Oh, hey, here’s a bunch of plot we shoe-horned in and decided to bring up 17 hours in” method of storytelling is something this show has done the whole season. Maybe we can call it the “Bill Hastings’s Web Site” method.

 

5. Where the hell is Audrey? And why should we care? The first question would seem to be answered at the end of Part 16- in some kind of hospital. Of course, we can only infer that from the tiny amount we see of it. She could be in the bathroom of Horne’s Department Store, for all we know. The second question- who cares?- is never answered. I mean, we care, because we like Audrey. But Audrey takes, what, four episodes to get out of that house, get to the Roadhouse, do her dance, and wake up (maybe) in a hospital (maybe), shouting at Charlie who is actually a mirror (maybe) and, as far as we know, she has no significance to the story beyond that. Well, then why show us anything about her at all?

 

6. We do remember Sarah Palmer taking her goddamn face off and eating a trucker’s throat, right? That all happened in your version of that episode, too? Oh good. Because it’s never referenced again. Maybe she’s possessed by Judy. Except that the ideas that, a) Judy is the Thing In the Glass Box, B) the Thing In the Glass Box is the BOB-spewing entity in the Trinity atomic bomb whatsis, c) The Thing In the Glass Box is the symbol on the card/Hawk’s map… none of that is actually in the show. At all.

 

7. Look, we need to talk about Annie. I’m sorry, but we do. I don’t much like her either, but she’s important. She’s the whole reason Dale was lured into the Black Lodge. She’s the subject of the last line of the original show. And… I guess she doesn’t exist? Because Norma’s mom has now been dead since before the first season? Even though she was in the show? And she doesn’t have a sister? Remember when we noticed this discrepancy in the book, and Mark Frost said that it would all be explained? He lied. Look, I’m sorry, but he flat-out lied.

 

8. Why is “Red” in this show? At all?

 

9. Who the hell is Billy? Someone’s looking for him in the RR, Audrey is having a fling with him, and two girls in the Roadhouse talk about him. And, surprising no one, we are never told anything else. Why even talk about him at all? There’s this theory that many of the Roadhouse scenes are in Audrey’s head, but he is referenced in a non-Roadhouse scene, and it just brings us back to the Audrey story line going nowhere.

 

10. And the frogbug was what? And whose mouth did it crawl into? And why is the Woodsman putting everyone to sleep? What did any of that have to do with anything at all?

 

11. What is Hawk supposed to watch for, under the moon, on Blue Pine Mountain? Because- and I know this will shock you- this is never, ever mentioned again. So why mention it at all?

 

12. Why did the Fireman shit a golden globe of Laura Palmer out of his head? How did that impact the story, again? I’m sure I missed that somewhere in the 10 hours of Dougie Jones acting like a zombie. Surely this was addressed? That sequence looks like it was expensive. I would imagine it would be of no small import. Surely there would have been at least one reference to it again, somewhere in the 10 more hours they had left. I’m sure I missed it.

 

These aren’t red herrings. These are huge gaps in storytelling. I wonder if the answers to these questions were in the original script. It wouldn’t be the first time Lynch has decided, “Screw the script.”

 

Finally, while I liked the conclusion, did I miss any foreshadowing at all that would hint at what the hell that was all about? I am admittedly dense, and I may have missed all kinds of things.

 

Again, to reiterate: I really, really enjoyed the hell out of this 18 hour movie. But that list of eleven, up there… I think those are big weaknesses that need to be addressed.

 

ETA: So who hired Ray to kill Doppelcoop? Who called Doppelcoop in the hotel if it wasn't Jeffries? I mean, come on.

 

Pretty comprehensive list of loose threads, and I quoted in its entirety in case anyone missed it a few pages back. I wasn't bothere by the Judy thing, or the mystery of the Fireman and his orb, but otherwise I agree. It's kind of aggravating to me to see it all laid out. I never expected answers to everything. I didn't expect a clean ending and a nice wrap-up, but things like the Hawk/Blue Pine Mountain story just disappearing entirely, likewise Sarah Palmer's monster, is beyond frustrating to me considering we had 2 hours for Lynch to do something, anything, with all these pieces of the world he spent 16 hours constructing for us previously. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Frohike said:

I also think that it's significant that the powerful "negative" force has a name that is possibly based on the Chinese verb "to explain" (jiao dai):

http://dictionary.pinpinchinese.com/definitions/t/交待-jiaodai

 

Like the will to lock everything down and assign linear meaning is somehow an implicitly destructive force.

http://dictionary.pinpinchinese.com/definitions/s/胶带-jiaodai

 

As a noun, it means "Recording tape." Guess it was Diane the whole time :o

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Quick overview of my reaction to the finale:

 

I think wrapping up the Evil Coop story line the way he did, Lynch was clearly expressing a lack of interest in "resolution" and was openly making fun of the audience. I saw episode 17 as a sort of parody of a "series finale" and episode 18 as a more pure expression of what Lynch is about, which seems to be a pretty bleak and hopeless assessment of the state of the modern world. 

 

The fact that a lot was left unresolved (e.g. Audrey) and the resolutions that we did get were willfully absurd (guy with a magic gardening glove punching a Bob rock)...this struck me as being mean-spirited on Lynch's part...it didn't just feel like the normal sort of TP parody, where he is taking tropes from, say, soap operas to a more extreme level. The side-character with a magic glove stuff...it was just rushed and (by design) hard to take seriously. In a lot of ways, the 2-part finale reminded me of the films of Michael Haneke, where he often uses stories and characters to undermine expectations and scold the audience. His stuff is beautifully made and, like Lynch this season,  kind of dickish. 

 

Fuck getting scolded, I didn't really need that. There are plenty of ways to undermine tropes and expectations without talking down to the audience.

 

And 18 was just a straight up bummer. Cooper clearly had evolved into a Good/Evil hybrid... and he's continuing to struggle against forces he's not able to comprehend, grapple with. I didn't need anything easy or tidy...I assumed there would be zero resolution, this being a full blown Lynch experience. What I didn't expect was something this bitter. I couldn't help but feel like Lynch took all of his frustrations over narrative expectations and used them against the characters. Cooper's failure could have been a statement about how we navigate human existence..it could have been despairing and meaningful at the same time. Instead it just felt like Lynch's antagonistic swipe at the audience. 

 

In TP discussions, it is often mentioned that Lynch never wanted to reveal Laura's killer and chafed over the narrative rules of television. Season 3 felt like a reaction to that overall frustration. It felt like he got bogged down in engineering this cosmic Rube-Goldberg story that was designed to once again leave Cooper in a failed, lost state. As much as I enjoyed watching the return overall, the finale retroactively undid a lot of that enjoyment by making so many events from this season feel even more senseless and petty than they did upon first viewing.

 

I stopped being a TP fan last night. I get the feeling this is exactly what Lynch wanted. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it's really telling how people are so passionate about it being a bitter, sad, hateful ending when I can't read it any other way than uplifting and positive. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At the end of episode 18, Laura is alive, knows who she is, and is back in Twin Peaks. Cooper succeeded in saving her. BOB is in the Lodge again, and will remain there. There are loose ends to tie up, but they're in a better position to do so than ever before. Chalfont/Tremond tried to trick Coop and Laura into walking away into the darkness, forgetting everything that happened, and living a life lost, empty, and filled with pain, but it didn't work. Laura still woke up from the dream.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, anoldtoilet said:

At the end of episode 18, Laura is alive, knows who she is, and is back in Twin Peaks. Cooper succeeded in saving her. BOB is in the Lodge again, and will remain there. There are loose ends to tie up, but they're in a better position to do so than ever before. Chalfont/Tremond tried to trick Coop and Laura into walking away into the darkness, forgetting everything that happened, and living a life lost, empty, and filled with pain, but it didn't work. Laura still woke up from the dream.

 

But it isn't Twin Peaks. That's how I read it: this is an alternate world/reality, where nothing is the same: not even Cooper.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, pabosher said:

 

But it isn't Twin Peaks. That's how I read it: this is an alternate world/reality, where nothing is the same: not even Cooper.

Diane might not have been the same, but Cooper is. He reads the note addressed to Richard like he has no idea what Linda is talking about, and then later in the same episode introduces himself as Agent Dale Cooper.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, anoldtoilet said:

Diane might not have been the same, but Cooper is. He reads the note addressed to Richard like he has no idea what Linda is talking about, and then later in the same episode introduces himself as Agent Dale Cooper.

 

He isn't the Dale Cooper from S1/2 or S3 E16/17 though. I agree with you that he *is* the same physical being, but I don't think he is the same person.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hi.

first, allow me to say thanx to jake and chris for some amazing discussions on each episode.

 

as for episode 17 and 18 of the return, allow me to offer some pointers, that might help you with interpreting what the hell lynch and frost were up to with this series.

sorry for my lack of caps, but my keyboard is busted.

i had to think for a while, after sheryl lee's final haunting scream transported us into a momentarily comatose state of despair.

now i'm almost angry at myself for not figuring it out sooner - figuring out what lynch and frost were really going for with twin peaks the return. but i think it essentially boils down to this: much of lynch's work center around duality.

while we have enjoyed many character moments of all sorts, nostalgia and tp mythology explored further in this season, there has been a constant underlying current of much greater ambition and horrific implications with us during the whole trip. we witnessed its birth in the now infamous episode 8 and it simply deals with a perverse interpretation of the episode 17 title 'the past dictates the future'.

for cooper, it dealt with the possibility of changing the past in order to rectify the future. for a brief emotional moment, we the viewers, were led to believe that he pulled it off. laura palmer took his hand.

but that narrative is crushed by the inevitability of what also happened in the past; humankind gave birth to the fury of evils own momentum and there is no stopping it. it doesn't matter what cooper does or doesn't do - from this moment on and until the end of our existence, we are forever trapped in the moment of laura's horrific echoing scream.

 

coopers arc echoes freds arc in lost highway. these created realities of their own making, will only present the exact same evils they are running away from. you can keep evil at bay, but never defeat it outright. cooper thinks he can by saving laura (which is a sign of human arrogance), but maybe laura was never meant to be saved. she was meant to die. and so it will be in every new iteration of reality that cooper and laura are doomed to repeat forever.

 

albert said back in season 2. bob is the evil that man does. how right he was.

 

these were my initial thoughts. hope they can guide some of you, if needed. :)

 

interesting note - the two episodes that went really deep with the inevitability of evil in our world, both has the number 8 in them - episodes 8 and 18. the infinity symbol that jeffries conjures from the owl symbol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The idea that David Lynch is in any way interested in creating a TV series simply to be antagonistic or say "screw you" to his audience is absurd to me. Why would anyone bother creating art, let alone such personal, creative, difficult-to-parse art if their only goal was to make others mad? Dude puts his life into this stuff, and it's clear when you listen to him speak that he holds within himself a deep love and respect for humanity, and some sort of desire to share something with all of us. These interpretations just read completely hollow to me. I understand being upset that the show didn't resolve properly (I was kinda bothered by Episode 18 at first), but I don't think there's any need to devalue the work like that.

 

The more I think about this finale, the more I appreciate it. A lot of that is thanks to the discussion on here, and giving myself some time to reflect. Even with my expectations set to "this is gonna be strange", I was still surprised by the ending. Distilling the story back to Cooper and Laura, and Coop's final attempt to save her. It's just incredible. That final scream is absolutely haunting. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just responding to a sentiment that bugs me in general:

 

At no point did I think Lynch was trolling the audience.  If you take 17 as a trolling of a series finale, then you're ignoring that he spent 16 episodes laying the groundwork to make 17 work on a plot and an emotional level. It would make the entire season an experiment in trolling, which is perhaps the most troll-y response to this delicately beautiful show that I could possibly imagine.

 

If I had to take a meaning from Twin Peaks, I'd say that monsters can be defeated, but there is always another monster waiting around the corner. But that bleak reality doesn't relieve us of our responsibility to still try to defeat every single monster we come upon.

 

In a way, he tells the same story that Cervantes told way back when he invented the modern narrative. It's all about tilting at windmills, because otherwise what the fuck else are we going to do?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi I'm a long time lurker, first time poster.. I've loved S3 for a number of reasons. It has been visually stunning, funny and has kept me thinking about it for days after each episode. The podcast has been great too!   I watched the original run as an 11/12 year old kid when it was originally aired. If you were to tell me then that Bob would leave evil Coop in a globe shaped piñata to be smashed by a character wearing a magic glove... I would have probably found it odds with the general ethos of the show.  I really enjoyed it none the less.  Like others, I found episode 18 challenging. I was very tired watching it and I might have to see it again.  The sex scene felt unpleasant, the identity of the alternative world was grimy and unwelcoming.  I felt unsettled, which beats the feeling of terror the last time I watched a TP season finale, do I want to know about the loose ends? Of course.  Do I want more right now? No,  I need to let that sink in first. Well done Lynch that was sensational stuff.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, WickedCestus said:

The idea that David Lynch is in any way interested in creating a TV series simply to be antagonistic or say "screw you" to his audience is absurd to me. Why would anyone bother creating art, let alone such personal, creative, difficult-to-parse art if their only goal was to make others mad? Dude puts his life into this stuff, and it's clear when you listen to him speak that he holds within himself a deep love and respect for humanity, and some sort of desire to share something with all of us. These interpretations just read completely hollow to me. I understand being upset that the show didn't resolve properly (I was kinda bothered by Episode 18 at first), but I don't think there's any need to devalue the work like that.

 

The more I think about this finale, the more I appreciate it. A lot of that is thanks to the discussion on here, and giving myself some time to reflect. Even with my expectations set to "this is gonna be strange", I was still surprised by the ending. Distilling the story back to Cooper and Laura, and Coop's final attempt to save her. It's just incredible. That final scream is absolutely haunting. 

 

Yeah, I'm not so sure about this.  It's like playing a joke on an animal or a child, maybe you're not doing it to be mean, maybe you think it is funny.  Lynch and Frost antagonized their audience in almost every episode, the only time I thought it was funny was when Coop was in the coma and someone said something to the effect of "He may never come out of it." That was all the audience needed waiting for Dougie to wake up and then have him in a coma for the rest of the season.  He wakes up in the next scene.  You got me Lynch.  I mentioned a bunch of the other trolling in previous posts, so I won't rehash them, but ask yourself this did any of the Candie scenes or Jacoby scenes serve any purpose, move the story or reveal character or plot, and when plot was revealed was it often rushed and unsatisfying.  

 

Take Freddie, we are introduced to him in an exposition dump he gives to James.  Now imagine instead of that we get to see this happening on screen asshole Freddie in his sad life, gets a visit from the Fireman.  Revelation! We witness his attempt to buy the glove and tension! he can't seem to get it, then wham, the glove is real and has real power as we see him clock the teller.  Maybe he tries to go back to his old life; it sucks, he heads to Twin Peaks and now we see the town through his eyes, we see the inhabitants we missed through him, we see how they've changed,  and we have him set up in a heroic arc so when his showdown with BOB comes it means something.  Isn't that more interesting?   Take some time with any of the characters, Jerry Horne and his bizarre 500 mile journey, Ben Horne and his new mistress- was the a reason we had those scenes or met her husband one time?  Audrey is introduced near the end of the season, can't seem to leave a room, leaves the room, dances and wakes up somewhere?  Tammy Preston spends her time vamping, giving knowing looks, or confused looks (a shame because I loved her in the book) and the reason she's important is because one time Cole said she was top of her class and impressive- did we get to see her be impressive?   Episode 18- lots of driving and empty stares.  What does Coop know or not know?  What was Diane seeing when she was having sex?  Why were they having sex?  Is that why they were at the hotel?  Why does Diane not react to seeing herself?  Was she switched when Coop came back?  All of those are fun questions that won't be answered, but really don't need to be mysteries.  Would you rather have those questions answered or more dialogue at the roadhouse which may or may not be real and may or may not be about characters we've seen (but under different names)?  What was the greater or deeper meaning of any of that?  Is questioning it devaluing it, or placing the appropriate value upon it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now